Tayshia’s bagel choice on The Bachelorette is a major red flag

why tayshia's order might be a dealbreaker

Bagels made a surprise appearance on S16 E11 of the Bachelorette!

Tayshia and the four remaining men have “hometown” dates at the resort.

Zac says he is from New York:

Not sure how Haddonfield, NJ is considered “New York”:

But it’s reality TV, so we’re willing to suspend disbelief.

Zac and Tayshia hop into a yellow taxi. Where is the first stop?


Brilliant move by Zac. There is no better way to get a gorgeous girl to fall in love with you than with bagels.

Time to check out the spreads:

Wait a second…

Is that…asparagus?

And are those…gummy bears?? And sour gummy worms??? 

What in the actual fuck, Bachelorette producers!?

Surely the options at La Quinta are limited, but these are an affront to bagel-lovers everywhere.

Tayshia tells Zac she’s going for a bagel with plain cream cheese and blueberries.

Zac reacts as any New Yorker would:

We all know what Zac’s thinking here. That’s the: “Are you fucking kidding me?” look

To Zac’s credit, he says as much, telling Tayshia “I don’t know if I can trust a girl that eats blueberry on their cream cheese bagel.”

Major kudos to Zac for calling Tayshia out, and honestly, huge red flag from Tayshia. This interaction alone might be a dealbreaker…

Nonetheless, this portion of the date ends with a crunchy bite, and the two love-birds continue on:

Someday, we’ll produce a spinoff called The Bagelorette

In the meantime, we’ll keep you updated if bagels make any more appearances on the normal show.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit

Leave a Comment